Peter Brandt is a veteran futures trader known for classical chart patterns and for being unusually open about his losses. The details below are as he has described them in interviews. They are self-reported, so treat them as his account.
The setback
Brandt placed his first trade in 1974 and went full time in the business in 1975. For years he cycled through methods, from point-and-figure charts to cycles and spreads, before finding classical charting around 1978. By his account his first profitable half-year came in the second half of 1979, and his first profitable full year in 1980, around five years after his first trade. Along the way he has recalled drawdowns of about 35% and 38%, and larger ones measured on open positions. He has said an income from brokerage work kept him afloat while he learned.
About five years from first trade to a profitable year
As Brandt has described it: his first trade in 1974, years of trying methods, and the first profitable half-year in late 1979 and full year in 1980. Self-reported, and he says three to five years is a realistic apprenticeship.
What he says changed
- Smaller drawdown targets. He first aimed to keep his worst drawdown within 20%, then 10%, and today aims to keep yearly drawdowns very small. He has said he hates drawdowns because you must earn the same money again.
- The same small risk on every trade. He now risks well under one percent of the account per trade, and has said so publicly.
- Expect to lose. He treats each new trade as likely to lose, which keeps the focus on risk. He has said that a win rate around 54% over many years is normal, and that high win rates are unrealistic for most traders.
- Strong opinions, weakly held. He drops a view when price proves him wrong, instead of defending it.
- Expect a long apprenticeship. He has said three to five years to become consistently profitable is realistic, and that the main job during that time is protecting capital.
The part most stories skip
Brandt had other income during those early years. Having a day job or reserve while learning, instead of needing the account to pay the bills, is part of why he stayed long enough to improve.
What a retail trader can take from it
Most new traders expect results in months and quit or blow up in the first year (see why most new traders lose money). Brandt's account points the other way: a longer timeline, small fixed risk (see position sizing), and a plan to protect capital while you learn. His specific rules are his own, not a recommendation.