Bill Lipschutz (his name is also spelled Lipschultz) is a currency trader who was profiled in Jack Schwager's The New Market Wizards and later led the foreign exchange trading desk at Salomon Brothers. Accounts of his career differ on dates and figures, so this lesson sticks to the broad story as he has told it.
The setback
While studying architecture at Cornell, Lipschutz inherited a portfolio of stocks from his grandmother, worth about $12,000 according to published profiles. He turned it into his trading capital and, by those accounts, grew the account to roughly $250,000 while still at university. He then nearly lost it. By his telling, the problem was one position that was far too large for the account. His analysis was not necessarily wrong, but the size meant that a bad move could do enormous damage.
Same price move, different position size
Illustrative, not real figures: with a position several times the size of the account, an ordinary adverse move can erase most of it. A position sized for survival takes the same move as a dent.
What he says changed
- Size is a separate decision from direction. A position has to be survivable relative to the account, even when you are confident in the idea.
- Feel the loss, do not hide from it. He has said traders should feel the pain of a loss rather than become numb to it, because numbness leads to gambling.
- Demand a worthwhile reward. He has talked about wanting a reward at least several times the risk on a trade, so being wrong often is still survivable.
- Trade less. He has suggested that doing nothing for a good part of the time would improve many traders' results.
After rebuilding the account, he moved to Salomon Brothers, where he became head of foreign exchange trading. Published figures for his results there vary, so they are left out here.
Why this one matters on a forex account
Leverage makes the Lipschutz mistake easy to repeat. One oversized position is how many accounts end, even when the market view turns out partly right.
What a retail trader can take from it
Before the entry, decide the size from the stop distance and a fixed small share of the account, not from how sure you feel (see leverage and margin and risk of ruin). A lost account that is rebuilt is a story that is told because the person survived to tell it. Many do not.