Bill Ackman founded the hedge fund Pershing Square in 2004 with about $54 million. Because he often announces large positions publicly, his wins and losses are unusually visible. The figures below are as reported in public sources, not verified here.
The setback
Two high-profile positions went badly. In March 2017 Pershing Square sold its remaining Valeant shares for roughly $300 million at a substantial loss, with press reports putting the total loss near $4 billion. Separately, a $1 billion short position against Herbalife, announced in December 2012, was closed at a loss in February 2018. Performance was weak across 2015–2018, and after that, by public accounts, he reworked how the firm was managed.
A small, steady cost against one large payoff
Reported figures, drawn to scale: Pershing Square disclosed $27 million spent on credit protection in early 2020, and said it produced $2.6 billion within weeks as markets fell. Most of the time a hedge like this costs money and pays nothing, so one payoff is not proof of a method.
The turn
The fund reportedly returned 58.1% the year after that rework. In early 2020 Pershing Square disclosed it had spent about $27 million on credit protection, and said that position produced about $2.6 billion in under a month as markets fell. Both figures are as reported by the fund and press.
What the story shows
- Concentration magnifies mistakes. Few, large positions can produce spectacular gains and spectacular losses (see diversifying strategies).
- Hedges cost money most of the time. Paying a small, steady cost for protection that rarely pays is a trade-off, not a free lunch.
- One payoff is not proof. A large gain from one well-timed hedge does not show that the method works repeatedly.
- Reviewing a bad stretch is part of the job. Changing process after losses, instead of defending it, is what he describes doing.
What a retail trader can take from it
Few retail accounts can afford a position whose loss would be a billion-dollar headline, but the proportions apply. Keep any one idea small enough that being wrong is survivable, treat hedging costs as real costs, and review a poor stretch with a written rebuilding plan before taking more risk.