Once a trader has one strategy that's been backtested, journaled, and traded consistently for a meaningful stretch, a natural next question appears: should there be a second one? Diversification across strategies is a legitimate way to smooth an equity curve, but it only works under a specific condition that gets skipped over surprisingly often.
The condition that actually matters: correlation, not count
Adding a second strategy only helps if its wins and losses don't line up with the first strategy's wins and losses. Two trend-following systems on correlated currency pairs (see the lesson on currency correlations) will tend to win together and lose together — that's not diversification, it's the same bet sized up and spread across two tickets. Genuine diversification comes from combining approaches that respond differently to the same market conditions: a trend-following system paired with a mean-reversion system, for example, or strategies operating on clearly different timeframes, since a choppy range that hurts a trend-follower can be exactly the condition a range-trading approach is built for.
What diversification actually buys you
The benefit isn't a higher win rate or bigger average win — it's a smoother overall equity curve, because the strategies' individual drawdown periods don't perfectly overlap. When strategy A is in its expected rough patch, strategy B may be performing normally, which reduces the chance that the whole account is deep in drawdown at the same time from the same underlying cause. This is a risk-management benefit, not a returns-boosting one, and it's worth being clear-eyed about that distinction from the start.
The real cost: spreading attention and capital too thin
Running multiple strategies means tracking multiple sets of rules, multiple journals, and dividing the same account's risk budget across more positions. A trader who hasn't fully mastered one strategy — who still second-guesses entries or breaks rules under pressure — rarely improves that situation by adding a second, unmastered strategy on top. Diversifying too early, or across too many approaches, tends to produce a diluted version of several strategies rather than genuine edge in any of them.
Diversifying too early
Adding a second strategy before the first is consistently, demonstrably profitable and well-understood. Usually just doubles the number of ways to make undisciplined mistakes.
Diversifying deliberately
Adding a second, genuinely uncorrelated approach only after the first has a solid track record, with risk explicitly divided between them rather than simply added.
A practical starting point
- Don't add a second strategy to "fix" a struggling first one — fix the first one, or stop trading it, before expanding
- Check correlation honestly: would the two strategies have lost money in the same historical periods, based on backtesting or journal data?
- Split risk explicitly between strategies at the position-sizing level, rather than letting overall exposure grow by simply running both at full size
- Journal each strategy's trades separately, so a shared log doesn't obscure which approach is actually driving results