Every forex broker fits into one of a few basic execution models, and the model matters more than most beginners realize — it determines how your order actually gets filled, who's taking the other side of it, and where potential conflicts of interest can show up. The marketing terms brokers use ("ECN," "STP," "raw spread") are really describing this underlying plumbing.
The core split: dealing desk vs. no dealing desk
The most important distinction is whether a broker operates a "dealing desk." A dealing desk broker can take the other side of your trade internally — when you buy, the broker's own book can effectively sell to you, rather than routing your order out to the wider market. A no-dealing-desk broker instead passes your order through to external liquidity providers, banks, or an exchange-like network, so your trade is matched with other real market participants.
Where your order actually goes
Market Maker Dealing desk
Sets its own bid/ask prices and can fill client orders internally rather than routing them to the broader market. This lets market makers offer fixed spreads and very small (or no) minimum deposits, since they aren't paying external liquidity providers per trade. The tradeoff is a structural conflict of interest: on some trades, the broker's profit and the client's profit are directly opposed, since the broker may be the counterparty. Reputable, regulated market makers manage this with internal controls and hedging, but it's worth understanding the structure exists.
ECN No dealing desk
Electronic Communication Network brokers route orders directly into a pool of liquidity from multiple banks, financial institutions, and other traders, matching buyers and sellers electronically. Pricing reflects the real market — spreads float and can be extremely tight, but brokers typically charge a separate commission per trade since they aren't earning from a spread markup.
STP No dealing desk
Straight Through Processing brokers automatically route client orders directly to their liquidity providers (often banks or larger brokers) without any dealing desk intervention. It's similar in spirit to ECN — no internal counterparty conflict — but STP brokers may route to a smaller set of liquidity providers rather than a full open network, and often build their fee into the spread rather than charging commission separately.
DMA No dealing desk
Direct Market Access gives traders the most transparent view of the underlying market — orders go straight into the real order book of the liquidity venue, and traders can often see the actual depth of buy and sell orders at different price levels. It's typically aimed at more advanced or higher-volume traders who want maximum transparency into pricing.
Hybrid
Many brokers today don't fit neatly into one category — they may operate a hybrid model, routing larger or more sophisticated accounts to ECN/STP execution while handling smaller retail accounts through a dealing desk. This is common enough that it's worth asking a broker directly which model applies to your specific account type, rather than assuming from their marketing.
| Model | Who sets the price | Typical cost structure | Counterparty conflict? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market Maker | The broker | Fixed or wider spread, often $0 commission | Possible |
| ECN | The open market | Tight floating spread + commission | No |
| STP | Liquidity providers | Floating spread, sometimes + commission | No |
| DMA | The order book directly | Market spread + commission | No |
Why this matters more than the marketing terms suggest
None of these models is automatically "the best" — a regulated market maker can be a perfectly reasonable choice, especially for a smaller account where commission-based ECN pricing might actually cost more overall. What matters is understanding which model a broker uses, so you know how their pricing works and whether a structural conflict of interest is part of the arrangement. That's a more useful question than chasing whichever label sounds most professional.